Sunday, April 1, 2012
Blogging
After reading about the activity in the article, I felt that it would not work nearly as well in a secondary setting. Having students who are fully capable of understanding online blogging create their own colorfully decorated paper blogs seems demeaning to me. I would entirely skip her activity of having the students create paper blogs, and simply have my high school students create real blogs. The only value I found in this piece were in the blogging rules and guidelines to commenting sections. I agree that properly citing information posted on blogs and avoiding plagiarism should be serious concerns when having students create their own blogs. I also agree that it must be made explicit that any form of cyber bullying or harassment will not be tolerated. Finally, I agree with the point about only posting things that benefit the learning experiences of participa ting members. However, I would take things a step further and require my students to support their opinions with evidence found from the internet. From my experience, blogs can be a haven for unsupported beliefs, a practice which I would not tolerate in my classroom.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I never really thought about the activity of paper blogging as demeaning but after reading your blog post I totally get what you're saying. Students today probably know more than we do about technology and so the concept of blogging is probably second nature to them. I think that as long as they understand the seriousness of the assignment and the rules they need to follow, secondary students should have no problem with a blogging task.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Peter. This activity resembles an introductory tool for blogging, however most secondary ed students are already accustomed to using the internet and blogs.
ReplyDelete